A well-regarded Bunn replacement carafe with a 4.7 rating from 265 buyers, though the 3-lb weight and $49.85 price mean it is best suited to buyers who specifically need this OEM part.
Bunn coffee maker owners who need the specific 42400.0103 replacement with a black handle and want the confidence of an OEM part at mid-range cost.
Skip if
You want a lightweight carafe, are working with a tight budget, or need a universal replacement that fits multiple brewer brands.
Color Black Handle
Weight 3.0 lb
Priced 13% above the category median ($44.05 across 10 tracked models)
Weight of 3.0 lb - heavier than 80% of the 11 models we track
Our scorecard
4.6/5overall
Owner rating4.7/5
4.7 average across 265 owner ratings
Popularity2.7/5
265 owner reviews, more than most models here
The overall score is owner satisfaction weighted by how many reviews back it, so a high rating from few reviews counts for less. The bars below show where this model stands against the other coffee makers, kettles and brewers we track in this category on price, popularity and size. Context, not marks against it, and our read of the data, not a lab test.
Overview
The Bunn 42400.0103 carries a black handle and weighs 3 lbs, which puts it on the heavier end of the carafes reviewed here. It is priced at $49.85, which is mid-range for Bunn OEM replacement options. The 4.7 rating from 265 buyers suggests that once people get the right part, they are very happy with it.
Bunn's commercial background means their carafes are built to take repeated hot fills and the kind of daily use you see in an office or busy household. The black handle keeps the look neutral and matches the black trim on most Bunn home brewers. The 3-lb empty weight is noticeable but is consistent with durable glass construction.
At $49.85 this is not a cheap replacement, and the heavier build may not appeal to everyone. But the 4.7 score on 265 reviews is a reliable signal that buyers who need this specific Bunn carafe are getting what they expected.
Pros
4.7 rating from 265 buyers is a strong confidence signal
Black handle matches Bunn home brewer aesthetics
OEM part ensures accurate fit with compatible Bunn machines
Durable construction suited to frequent, hot-fill use
Cons
At 3 lbs empty, this is noticeably heavier than many carafes
$49.85 is near the higher end for a replacement carafe
No capacity or dishwasher-safe spec published
Performance notes
Buyers confirm accurate fit and a clean, no-drip pour on compatible Bunn machines. The heavier glass gets some acknowledgment in reviews, though most see it as a sign of durability rather than a drawback. No notable reports of early cracking or lid misalignment.
What buyers say
265 reviews at 4.7 reflects a satisfied buyer base that largely consists of direct replacement purchasers. Praise focuses on fit accuracy and build quality. The few lower ratings trace to buyers who received a carafe that did not match their specific Bunn model, rather than quality issues with the carafe itself.
The 3-lb weight reflects heavier glass construction typical of Bunn's commercial-oriented carafes. This tends to make them more durable but noticeably heavier when pouring a full pot.
Is the Bunn 42400.0103 the same as the 42401.0101?
No. They are different Bunn replacement carafes with different part numbers, different handle colors (black versus orange), and different compatible brewer models. Always match the part number to your specific machine.
Is $49.85 the typical price for this Bunn carafe?
Prices can vary on Amazon, but $49.85 is consistent with mid-range Bunn OEM carafe pricing. Third-party alternatives exist at lower prices but may not fit as precisely.
We use necessary cookies to keep the site working. With your permission, we also use functional, analytics, and marketing cookies. Read our Cookie Policy.
