At $17.22 with a 4.8 rating from 274 buyers, this orange-accented Bunn carafe punches well above its price and is one of the best-value OEM replacement options in the category.
Budget-conscious Bunn owners who need a dependable replacement carafe without spending $50 or more on a premium OEM part.
Skip if
You need a carafe with a black or neutral handle, or your Bunn model requires a different replacement part number.
Color Orange
Weight 1.2 lb
Priced 61% below the category median ($44.05 across 10 tracked models)
Weight of 1.2 lb - heavier than 60% of the 11 models we track
Our scorecard
4.7/5overall
Owner rating4.8/5
4.8 average across 274 owner ratings
Popularity3.2/5
274 owner reviews, more than most models here
The overall score is owner satisfaction weighted by how many reviews back it, so a high rating from few reviews counts for less. The bars below show where this model stands against the other coffee makers, kettles and brewers we track in this category on price, popularity and size. Context, not marks against it, and our read of the data, not a lab test.
Overview
The Bunn 42401.0101 stands out immediately for two reasons: its orange handle, which is a signature color on many Bunn commercial and home brewers, and its $17.22 price tag, which is a fraction of what other Bunn OEM carafes cost. The 4.8 rating across 274 reviews makes it one of the highest-rated carafes in this product set.
The orange handle is not just cosmetic. On Bunn machines, orange traditionally signals a decaf pot, which is useful in household and office settings where someone needs to tell at a glance which pot is which. That color-coding function adds real daily convenience for multi-pot setups.
At 1.2 lbs, this is a lightweight carafe that is easy to handle even when full. The combination of a near-perfect rating, sub-$20 price, and a practical handle color makes this one of the easier buying decisions in the Bunn carafe lineup.
Pros
4.8 rating from 274 buyers is among the highest in this category
$17.22 is significantly cheaper than most OEM Bunn replacements
Orange handle serves as a practical decaf identifier in multi-pot setups
Lightweight at 1.2 lbs for easy one-handed pouring
Cons
Orange handle is not suitable if you want a neutral or all-black look
No published capacity spec, so you have to verify it matches your brewer
Compatible only with select Bunn models
Performance notes
Buyers confirm the fit is accurate on compatible Bunn machines and that the carafe pours cleanly. The lightweight construction is noted positively, especially in office contexts where the pot is handled frequently. No significant reports of lid leakage or drip issues at this price point.
What buyers say
A 4.8 average on 274 reviews is exceptional for a replacement carafe. Reviewers love the value, the color-coding utility, and the straightforward fit. The handful of lower ratings trace to model incompatibility rather than product defects.
Why does the Bunn 42401.0101 have an orange handle?
On Bunn machines, orange is the standard color for decaf pots. It lets anyone in a kitchen or office know at a glance which carafe holds the decaf brew without reading a label.
How much does the Bunn 42401.0101 weigh?
It weighs 1.2 lbs empty, making it one of the lighter carafes in Bunn's lineup. That lightness is noticeable when pouring a full pot.
Is $17.22 an unusually low price for a Bunn OEM carafe?
Yes. Most Bunn replacement carafes list significantly higher. The low price appears to reflect this model's simpler construction, and the 4.8 buyer rating suggests quality is not compromised.
We use necessary cookies to keep the site working. With your permission, we also use functional, analytics, and marketing cookies. Read our Cookie Policy.
